Benny's Pizza - Pleasant Valley, NY - 18 W Rd - Hours, Menu, Order

Our Menu

Order through our site for the best value, faster service, and a direct way to support your local favorites.

House Favorites

Cheese Pizza

$11.99

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

Out of stock
Drunk Grandma's Pizza

$24.99

Thin Crust, house-made vodka sauce, basil, olive oil, parmesan, fresh mozzarella.

Out of stock
Drunk Grandma's with Hot Honey & Pepperoni Pizza

$24.99

Thin crust, house-made vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella & pepperoni cups with hot honey drizzle.

Out of stock

View Full Menu

Our Story

There's always more at Benny's Pizza

What people are saying

What our customers are saying about Benny's Pizza

4.7

2.3K Ratings

Jun 26, 2026

Jennifer B.

Best margarita pizza I’ve ever had in my life

Find Us

Address: 18 W Rd Pleasant Valley, NY 12569

Call: (845) 723-4482